Hi Fred
I'm sorry that it has taken me a long time to get back to you. You post came over the weekend and due to a water pipe leak in my front yard I neglected to check the forum.
It seems as if though you have answered your own question in the mean time. I have to admit when I was starting to learn about oolongs the first couple of times I tried what I thought was good Da Hong Pao, I thought 'Well so what?'. Luckily though I did get some good Da Hong Pao, and it blew me away. It is so rich and complicated.
Just a word about the fragrance in relationship to the taste. The lighter roasted DHP has better fragrance that the more roasted DHP. I asked Master Liu this year to do a light roasting to let our customers see the difference, but DHP isn't usually light roasted. I haven't decided whether or not I will ask for that roasting again, and I encourage you to try the other roasting too. I think that you will discover that same kind of complication with other rock oolongs and oolongs in general, pay special attention to the aftertaste. I also would encourage you to up the amount of tea that you are using. With good quality tea you don't need to worry much about bitterness. I think that you should always err on the strong side than the weak, but that my person taste.
Please don't be intimidated by tea snobbery. Authentic tea people rarely are snobs, and the Chinese say, 'You can study tea for a lifetime and never learn all of the names of all of tea teas'. If there are few tea experts in China amongst the masters that devote their lives to tea, how many people can justify their snobbery?
Please enjoy you learning and never feel as if you asking a stupid question on our forum.
Austin